Member Submitted

New Super Mario Bros. 2 - Not worth the price of admission

by rizzod 16 Comments 26 Votes 3028 Views 19/08/2012 Back to Articles

So I just literally put my 3DS back into it's cradle, and have finished my first run of New Super Mario Bros. 2. Am I disappointed? No. Am I Satisfied? Not yet. Do I think it was worth the RRP of $69? Hell No! (That's why I picked it up from Big W.. $54 people, grab it for that.)

Anyway. This isn't going to be a review, it's going to be more about the quality and quantity of this title, and whether it was really worth the $54 - $70. So Let's Start this off.

So *New* Super Mario Bros. 2 obviously stuck to the same formula as it's predecessors did, but actually did more to re-hash than introduce anything that was new. The levels were fine, the music was "meh", and the design was pretty much what we have seen in the past games. It was... the same... Nintendo have seem to run out of design ideas for this game while making it, or they had designed this originally for the Wii U and decided to scrap it and place it on it's handheld. Remember when they announced "*New* Super Mario Bros. Mii" and it looked exactly the same as "*New* Super Mario Bros. Wii"? Well this game was an obvious rip of the Wii version, and made portable, now that the power of the 3DS can handle that. There was obvious take off's of Super Mario Bros. 3 in the game that was not subtle at all, and the Reznor Battles were outdated, to say the least. Beat those without breaking a sweat. Don't get me wrong, it's always nice to see a nostalgic throwback in a game, but a throwback should be in subtle doses. The Reznors were pretty much whored out by the 4th World. Every Mid-Fortress was a Reznor Battle.. they couldn't mix it up a little? Maybe have Bowser Jr in some Mid Fortress' or even a Boomer? That would have been epic to see his return in a 2D Platformer, stomp him once, Shell Spikes, *MAGIC WINGS*. Anyway, repetitive gameplay is a major issue in this game, which I hope Nintendo decide to fix once they start dishing us some DLC. Unfortunately we know at the moment the only DLC we get in this game will be for Coin Rush Mode, but hopefully Nintendo will come to their senses and give us something more to play with. Which brings me to our next Subject.

Oh boy, here's where it definitely hits hard. 6 Worlds. Only 6. (Excluding Star and the hidden worlds). Nintendo, I don't want to tell you what to do with your Mario games, or how they're designed, but everyone knows, and especially if you're a hardcore Mario Fan like myself, traditionally, Mario Games (Except Mario USA(2)) has 8 Worlds. Eight. Eight, regular worlds to complete this game. It is piss poor that you guys decided to cut out 2 worlds on us. If you were taking the traditional" *New* route, you completely cut Mountain and Forest. Not good enough. Every other Mario Game that you have released has had the decency of giving us that satisfaction, that "Over the line" feel to it, where there was EIGHT REGULAR WORLDS, and then the extra's. I feel completely ripped of those 2 worlds that led to the Quality that we have expected from you Nintendo. I don't know whether the case is that you guys have gotten lazy now? or whether it's that you are too busy with Wii U development? but the Mario Franchise is Nintendo. And we expect our Fill. Especially Australia, we expect our fair share, if you expect us to shill out $70 over your short arse, piss poor of an excuse. So do I feel ripped off? Yes. I only spent $54 on this game, and your excuse is.. did you collect 1,000,000 coins? NO! Because I know that the pay-off is probably going to be even more piss poor than what you gave us anyway. Your repetitive gameplay, repetitive music, repetitive bosses and complete rehashes, has the whole title of this game completely Wrong. It's not *New* Super Mario Bros. 2, It's "Super Mario Bros: Million Coin Challenge". Because at least *New* Super Mario Bros. had a sense of quality and quantity to it, because it was a fresh idea, that became great once you put it on the big screen to the Wii, but now I feel you're whoring it out. It was a Mario Adventure, that was a REAL DEAL Mario Adventure. Not some cheap-arse excuse to pick up the game to get a million coins. That's a real shameful excuse in my opinion. Now I still support you guys and I hope you don't let me down on *New* Super Mario Bros. U, I have already Pre-Ordered my Wii U, since June, and Am planning to get *New* Super Mario Bros. U on it, but maybe not right away now, this is the first time i'm actually going to wait out on getting one of your *New* games, and I can't believe it. I can't believe i'm actually second guessing a 1st person Mario Game here, but I am. I'm not completely disappointed Nintendo, but I am disappointed that you guys made me feel ripped, because there was just not enough, I finished the game in less that 4 hours. My 3DS Activity Log reads 3:25, that's the amount of time it took for me to complete this game, and I did not rush, and I did not try my best on it. Meaning I didn't Speed-Run nor did I spend all the time I had in each level to find each Gold coin, but I did the best I could. Now, that being said, that's just mind blowing. Anyway, Nintendo, release some REAL DLC, and give us some extra worlds damnit for a good price, 90c for a world, hell I'll buy that!

But I'm going to finish it off with this. I have deep faith in Nintendo, always have. But as of late, my faith has been toyed with. I wish sometimes Reggie would take off the suit and be straight with us, but as long as he's the prez, that's never going to happen. But, I'm not disappointed with Nintendo, nor am I completely disappointed with this game, I still think it's a good 3DS Title, it's not a strong one, But it's one that I will definitely revisit from time to time. BUT NOT WORTH THE MONEY, not even the Big W Price. My advice to anyone is this, and i'll give it to you in bullet points:




It's simple, the amount you get in this game, is not worth the price of admission. Wait for it to get below $50 and then it'll be worth it. Sorry Nintendo.
Link to us
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

New Super Mario Bros. 2 - Not worth the price of admission Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
Great read and couldn't agree with you more!
Disagree completely. I'm loving the title and fully intend on getting it complete 100%. I payed £29.99 for it here in the UK at retail and i feel i got my monies worth.

Nice rant though :P
@Heller Thanks mate, expect alot more from me.

@OllyEbbz If we were paying UK Price (Which is $45) then I would gladly retract the article, but we're expected to pay Not $10 (Unless Big W/Target) But $25 more (than the UK) for RRP. That's ridiculous.
Couldn't you have just voiced your displeasure in the thread for the game not used a whole article for it?

By the way I love the game.
i got this today and i really like it. I am glad i paid $54 for it from Big W and would happily do it for an aus-Pal game.
Sheesh, this game seems to be getting harsh reviews & opinions everywhere :S
I both agree and disagree with this article.

I think $70 is ridiculous for the download price. Almost anyone would agree.

(look out readers, wall of text :P )
I really love every bit of this game though. I've 'finished' it (unlocked all the worlds, final boss, etc), and from my experience so far, there's nothing I've found to dislike about it, except re-using nsmbwii's soundtrack.
It feels like a perfect mix between nsmb, smb3 and smw in many ways for me. All the stages are cleverly thought out and fun, the gameplay and physics feel smooth and leave the player in control which is how it should be.
As for the reznors, they did change the layout of each battle, wheras it could've just been the same room, same exact battle over and over.
Also, yoshi's island only had 6 worlds, and that was a great game. It's the levels and replay value that count.

I have to admit, I'd been very disappointed in nintendo for the past few years, I haven't had much fun with their more recent games honestly, so when I saw this at first I wasn't too impressed to say the least, especially being another 'new' super mario bros, that's definitely overdoing it. But, playing this game has restored my faith in nintendo. :)
@kangle4 no.
@gargoyles to each his own.
@yoshi888 im glad to hear that. I've been that way for a little while with Nintendo and the 3DS. They have been putting out some good content on their handheld, but this game, I just don't think Nintendo lived up to their true potential, and they know that too. If it's Mario, it's 100% or nothing. If you're shilling out a game for me to buy, it's gotta be good. If you're going to buy a game and say, "Oh Nintendo, you did a good job on this, wasn't the best but I still love you and that's why I give your game 5 stars and i'll buy it if it's $70 or $1,000" Then you are a complete Nintendo Fanboy, and an Idiot. You wouldn't buy a car if a salesmen said, "It's not the best in the line, it wont get you from A-B but it'll get you half-way there for the same price".
I still don't think the price is right yet... i was going to get it when the price drops if that ever happens... :/

TrblyXlent said: I still don't think the price is right yet... i was going to get it when the price drops if that ever happens... :/

You'll be lucky to get it for less than $60 after launch week. (unless you import a PAL copy online)

Tsunamo said:

TrblyXlent said: I still don't think the price is right yet... i was going to get it when the price drops if that ever happens... :/

You'll be lucky to get it for less than $60 after launch week. (unless you import a PAL copy online)

That's probably the smartest way to do it, probably from
I enjoy it, there is quite a lot of hif]dden things to find aswell which ads to it
I've been having a great time and can see myself going back for the golden coins later on. While I agree that the eShop price is ridiculous, I still didn't mind paying $55 from Target. I've payed a lot more for most of my other games anyway.

The one complaint I do have about it is the music. Blatantly pulled straight from the previous titles. While I still enjoy the music, It would've been nice to have something new.

kangle4 said: Couldn't you have just voiced your displeasure in the thread for the game not used a whole article for it?
By the way I love the game.

Kinda felt the same way. The game is awesome fun btw!
Its called an opinion piece, not a forum post.
S.U.B.T.L.E...subtle. Not 'suttle.' Best not to overuse a word when you cannot spell it.
ah crap, that's why you don't type an article at 2am after 3 beers lol.

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook

Recently Read

Featured Wii Content

GOTY 2015: Best Game Of 2015

GOTY 2015: Best Game Of 2015

22/12/2015 Polls 16 14
Friendly Fire Show 122: The Finale

Friendly Fire Show 122: The Finale

Podcast 21/03 Articles 7 6
Friendly Fire Show 121's The Divided
Podcast 15/03 Articles 3 3
Australian game sales approach $3b, mostly digital
maxiboy 13/03 News 5 10
Target store in SA displays games in plain packaging

Target store in SA displays games in plain packaging

maxiboy 13/03 News 5 11
Friendly Fire Show 120: I swear, by the Sun and Moon...
Podcast 02/03 Articles 2 1
Friendly Fire Show 119: Weekend at Tano's

Friendly Fire Show 119: Weekend at Tano's

Podcast 23/02 Articles 5 1
Friendly Fire Show 118: R.I.P. Tano

Friendly Fire Show 118: R.I.P. Tano

Podcast 11/02 Articles 3 3
Friendly Fire Show 117: It's not goodbye, it's Halo!

Friendly Fire Show 117: It's not goodbye, it's Halo!

Podcast 01/02 Articles 6 4

Community Content

Fallout-themed excuses to get the day off

Fallout-themed excuses to get the day off

09/11/2015 Blog 19 0

MMGN Updates


commented on Megaton Hammer

Roger439 21 hours ago

digitalgho just unlocked the Welcomed achievement!

digitalgho 3 days ago

canaldodg got Blacklight Retribution, DOOM, Call of Duty: Black Ops III, Bloodborne

canaldodg 27/04/2016

LoveIsMurder13 wants Fallout 4

LoveIsMurder13 26/04/2016

Wamuu is now Level 2!

Wamuu 25/04/2016

fitaang is now Level 2!

fitaang 25/04/2016

ZenModz is now Level 8!

ZenModz 19/04/2016

commented on Year in review: The worst-reviewed games of 2015

JanaR 18/04/2016

commented on Far Cry 3: Worth Getting?

JanaR 18/04/2016

emilywer12 is now Level 2!

emilywer12 14/04/2016